Better a Finch in the Hand is a short world quest at Port Belovodye in Genshin Impact 7.2. Ivanych runs a game where you break rock piles looking for prizes. The first two free picks give you two Common Chests. After you’ve paid for more turns and found nothing, investigating his setup reveals the scam. Confront him, win the fight and collect the Luxurious Chest.
Ivanych is counting on the first couple of chests making his game look tempting. The paid rounds are the giveaway: they stop producing prizes. You’re not meant to memorise a lucky left-middle-right sequence. You’re meant to go behind the rocks and catch him out.
Where to start Better a Finch in the Hand

Travel to Port Belovodye in the new Snezhnaya area. The quest marker appears east of the Teleport Waypoint south of the bridge. Find Ivanych beside the rock piles and talk to him about his game. Once you agree to try it, you can pick up the nearby Pickaxe and use it to break the selected ore.
If Better a Finch in the Hand isn’t showing on your map, check that you’ve reached the relevant Version 7.2 Snezhnaya area and have access to the construction and exploration mechanics introduced during Everwinter Without Mercy. Ivanych is a local NPC rather than an event-menu challenge, so you need to meet him at the site.
Better a Finch in the Hand: which rock pile should you choose?
| Stage | Best move | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| First two free tries | Pick any two piles | Two Common Chests, one from each pick |
| Paid rounds | Break two more piles, then continue the dialogue | You fail to uncover more rewards |
| Investigate the game | Go behind the piles and talk to Paimon | You realise Ivanych is fixing the game |
| Expose the scam | Break all three rock piles | No real treasure is hidden inside |
| Confront Ivanych | Defeat the enemies he calls | Quest ends and a Luxurious Chest appears |
Pick any two of the three piles for the free part and smash them with the provided Pickaxe. Each reveals a Common Chest. Ivanych then persuades you to pay Mora for more attempts. Make the additional picks and collect the bad news: there isn’t another prize waiting there.
If you’ve been trying to guess a magic combination for the paid rounds of Better a Finch in the Hand, stop worrying about which pile you chose. The route forward is the conversation with Paimon behind the rock piles. That’s what lets you investigate the game instead of paying for more disappointment.
How to expose Ivanych’s scam

After the disappointing paid tries, move behind the rock piles and speak with Paimon. This triggers the investigation into Ivanych’s setup. Pick up the pickaxe again and break all three piles, rather than choosing just the one the merchant wants. You’ll find that he hasn’t hidden the promised treasure there at all.
Ivanych doesn’t take being caught particularly well. After the argument, he summons enemies. Defeat them to finish the confrontation. The Luxurious Chest appears as the quest reward, separate from the small chests you received during the early free rounds.
Better a Finch in the Hand rewards
The final fight rewards a Luxurious Chest, in addition to the two Common Chests from the first free picks. That’s the complete treasure payoff from Better a Finch in the Hand. The other reward to remember isn’t another chest here: you can take the items from Ivanych’s activity to Vlast for a separate consignment storyline.
There’s also a useful follow-up tied to Vlast, the Opportunity Merchant in Downtown Novokitezhgrad. His rock-pile puzzle is a separate activity with three chest rewards, but completing both the Ivanych quest and Vlast’s challenge sets up the hidden consignment achievement Tales of Pearls Beneath the Dust. That’s a different search question, so we’ve linked its full trading and buyer guide instead of burying the details here.
Why Vlast won’t start the consignment after Ivanych
To unlock the later Vlast sales, finish Better a Finch in the Hand, complete Vlast’s own Gifts of Fate rock challenge, then speak to Vlast and hand over the items recovered from Ivanych for consignment. Only after that should you start repeatedly asking how the sales are going. The five-buyer storyline is a separate activity, covered in our related achievement guide.
It’s worth doing the two merchants together. Ivanych uses the rock piles to take your Mora; Vlast lets you win chests and eventually sell the treasures. They’re connected, but the two puzzles and the later buyer scenes have different rewards. In Better a Finch in the Hand, the solution is exposing the scam, not finding the perfect rock.
Better a Finch in the Hand: common stuck points
If the quest is stuck after you tried the paid game, look for the point behind the piles where you can speak with Paimon. If all three rocks are gone but the quest still hasn’t ended, finish the confrontation and defeat the enemies Ivanych summons. And if your goal is the secret achievement rather than the Luxurious Chest, head to Vlast afterwards; the consignment is not part of this quest’s final objective.
Better a Finch in the Hand is a good reminder that some Snezhnaya side quests are about paying attention to the characters, not solving a complicated combination lock. The free rounds are bait, the paid rounds are the scam, and the real prize is the chest you get after calling Ivanych out.
Official source: HoYoverse Version 7.2 update details.
