A Tail Tale in Disney Dreamlight Valley is Eeyore’s first chapter once you’ve opened Gloommeadow. He’s lost his tail again, and finding it involves building a home for a hedgehog, fishing up two rather hopeless replacements and playing Pooh Sticks.
Before you can fish up the real tail, you’ll try three substitute tails. Two come from the river, and Pooh finds an Umbrella Tail afterwards. You also need to photograph Eeyore trying each one before the Pooh Sticks game.
Find Eeyore in A Tail Tale in Disney Dreamlight Valley

After clearing the wall at the end of The Misplaced Honey, follow the path into Gloommeadow. You’ll find Eeyore a little further into the biome. Speak to him about his missing tail and the hedgehog who needs a home.
At a crafting station, make a Hedgehog Companion Home with 6 Hardwood, 5 Juniper Berries, 2 White & Pink Foxgloves and 6 Soft Limestone. The wood is gathered from the ground, berries come from bushes and limestone from the mining rocks.
Place the companion home outside, then find a hedgehog to feed. Hedgehogs curl up when approached, so wait for it to relax and offer food. Golden Honey or Pufflebud Pods are their favourites, although the quest doesn’t require you to unlock all four colour variants as companions.
How to get the Cuckoo Clock and Steel Spring tails in A Tail Tale in Disney Dreamlight Valley
Return to Eeyore near the Gloommeadow river. Use the Royal Pickaxe to clear the debris blocking the water. Once the river runs again, you’ll see two odd things floating downstream.
Fish them out to collect the Cuckoo Clock Tail and Steel Spring Tail. These are quest objects, not regular fish that appear in any water ripple. If they aren’t there, check that you’ve finished the hedgehog step and cleared the obstruction.
Give Eeyore the Cuckoo Clock Tail, take a photo of him wearing it and talk to him. Do the same with the Steel Spring Tail. Neither makes him especially happy.
Play Pooh Sticks during A Tail Tale in Disney Dreamlight Valley

Talk to Pooh about another idea. Follow him to the object in the ground and dig up the Umbrella Tail with your Shovel. Bring it to Eeyore, photograph him trying it and talk to him again. Pooh then suggests Pooh Sticks.
Meet Pooh and Eeyore at the Gloommeadow bridge and interact with the sign to play Pooh Sticks. The story only requires completing the activity, not winning every race.
Once the minigame is done, look at the water under the bridge and fish out Eeyore’s Tail. You’ll know it’s the correct item because the quest now asks you to return it, rather than presenting another unsuitable substitute.
Finish A Tail Tale in Disney Dreamlight Valley
Bring Eeyore’s real tail back to him and finish the conversation. That completes Chapter 4 and moves the story into The Big Red Monster, where you both investigate something suspicious in the fog.
If the real tail hasn’t appeared, check that you’ve photographed Eeyore trying all three substitutes, including Pooh’s Umbrella Tail, and spoken to him after each. Only then does the Pooh Sticks game lead to the real tail beneath the bridge.
A Tail Tale in Disney Dreamlight Valley isn’t about winning every Pooh Sticks race or collecting rare fish. It’s about following Eeyore’s little adventure in order. He gets his tail back, and for a moment at least, things are looking up for him.
Official source: Gameloft’s official Disney Dreamlight Valley guidance.
